Paul Scholes picks former Northern Ireland star's blunder as worst refereeing mistake ever
The Overlap debate 'great question' in latest show with the Stick to Football panel split on their answer
Referees are always coming in for stick over their decisions, but what is the worst of all time?
That's the question that was asked in the latest episode of the The Overlap Stick to Football show brought to you by Sky Bet, and it drew some interesting answers from the panel.
One former Northern Ireland international got an honourable mention but in the end though they found it hard to nail it down to one incident.
It was Gary Neville who posed the question with Paul Scholes plumping for a very memorable moment involving their former Manchester United teammate, Roy Carroll.
Carroll, who won 45 caps for Northern Ireland, got away with one when he spilled Pedro Mendes' speculative long-range effort into his own net in the goalless draw with Spurs back in January 2005.
Despite the ball being well over the line Carroll scooped it back and the officials remarkably played on.
Roy Keane though felt the linesman was to blame for that call rather than the referee, although he did praise Carroll for "getting away with it".
Neville felt Thierry Henry's double handball on the way to William Gallas scoring what turned out to be the winner for France over the Republic of Ireland in the play-off for the 2010 World Cup finals should be in with a shout.
Ian Wright, quickly responded saying: "Let's not bring that back up or we'll have the Irish back on him."
Frank Lampard's non-goal against Germany at the 2010 Wold Cup was also debated with Jill Scott suggesting Maradona's infamous 'Hand of God' goal against England at Mexico '86.
"It's got to be the worst one, it has to be. Even if there was VAR then they'd probably look at that 20 times," she said.
Keane cheekily joked: "Do you reckon he definitely handled that? I'm not sure he did."
Another World Cup incident from Spain '82 got Neville's vote when Toni Schumacher collided with Patrick Battiston when West Germany and France met in the semi-finals.
Schumacher escaped a red card despite the French star losing three teeth as a result of the challenge.
"Was Schumacher sent off for the one with Battiston," asked Neville. "That's got to be the worst one, either that or Maradonna."